South African President Cyril Ramaphosa meets Donald Trump on 21 May amid tensions over Washington's resettlement of white Afrikaners that the US president claims are the victims of "genocide." Photo: AFP
The US president was at his undiplomatic worst when his South African counterpart turned up at the Oval Office, but the ambush did swing the spotlight on what's happening there.
This story has been updated to clarify that footage shown by Donald Trump during his meeting with Cyril Ramaphosa was misleading.
Cathy is a 10th-generation white South African who moved to New Zealand 28 years ago, following the hijacking and killing of a man in her work car park.
Her parents, dyed-in-the-wool South Africans, followed her 10 years later, after someone broke into their home and left knives in the ceiling.
Today, from the safety of her Auckland home, she backs US President Donald Trump, who stunned the world last week with his orchestrated ambush of South African President Cyril Ramaphosa in the Oval Office.
Trump played videos that he claimed proved genocide is being committed against white people, driving farmers to flee to the US.
One part of the video came from the news agency Reuters and its fact check team has confirmed it shows humanitarian workers lifting body bags in the Congolese city of Goma, not South Africa.
Another part of the video showed what Trump claimed was 1000 crosses to mark the death of 1000 white farmers. They were in fact erected by volunteers protesting the death of two white farmers and did not mark actual graves. The video was made in September 2020.
The unexpected stunt turned the diplomatic setting into a stage for Trump's contention that white South Africans are being persecuted.
"I think that Donald Trump is a very astute gentleman," says Cathy, who didn't want her last name used.
"And I believe that what he has intended to do with his reaction and his approach to the situation in South Africa is to put a spotlight on it.
"Media companies around the world wouldn't be talking about it unless he'd done that. So, let's give him some credit."
She says the current South African government isn't standing up to the opposition, which is making threats to different racial communities.
In January, President Ramaphosa also signed a Bill into law allowing the state to seize land without compensation.
"A lot of the farmers and the Afrikaans community feel reasonably threatened by what is happening in the country," Cathy says.
"I know of people who have had to run for their lives, leaving their farms. I know of people who live in New Zealand who have had to return home because their families have been murdered. It is real, it is true, and I don't believe it's being reported on."
President Trump's meeting with President Ramaphosa in the White House was billed as a friendly conversation about trade and regional cooperation, but it quickly turned sour with the South African leader visibly blindsided by the white genocide ambush, which critics have labelled "inappropriate and undiplomatic".
Robert Patman, professor of international relations at Otago University, tells The Detail the stunt was performative, targeting MAGA supporters.
"I was appalled," he says. "It seems to me that America has humiliated itself - at least its president has humiliated America in the eyes of many people around the world.
"This is the second time that Mr Trump has applied 'gotcha' diplomacy, where he has ambushed someone in the Oval Office. It struck me as thoroughly unprofessional.
"If he had genuine concerns about white genocide, then he would have sent the documents in advance to the South African government to form the basis of a discussion... a discussion that would normally happen behind closed doors on sensitive issues.
"There is no basis in the allegations that Mr Trump has made. The whole thing was performative, and it may have won him some applause amongst MAGA supporters - Make America Great Again supporters - but it certainly hasn't won any international respect for the Trump administration."
He suggests that South Africa's genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice was another factor in the attack.
Patman also says a number of South African billionaires, including Elon Musk, have Trump's ear.
Earlier this month, a group of 59 white South Africans arrived in the United States after being granted refugee status by the White House, which has fast-tracked the processing of Afrikaner refugees but paused refugee applications for other nationalities.
This follows Trump freezing aid to South Africa in February over claims it was mistreating its minority white population.
President Ramaphosa has vehemently denied all the claims.
Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.
You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.
